Are organic tampons better? The truth about organic tampons
Why organic doesn’t mean zero risk
You’ve seen them on the supermarket shelves: Tampons proudly labeled organic—with a higher sticker price to match. The packaging says these tampons come with plant-based plastic applicators and are free from unnecessary chemicals. But what does that mean, exactly? Are these tampons better for your health? Will they protect you against toxic shock syndrome? Should you shell out the extra few bucks?
To get to the bottom of these questions, we at Flex® took a very close look at organic tampons. Turns out, organic tampons do provide some benefits—but those benefits don’t really have to do with your personal health. Read on to find out what exactly organic tampons are, and what protections they do—and don’t—provide.
What makes a period product “organic”?
Let’s start by looking at what the word “organic” means. In the U.S., “organic” is a term that’s regulated by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. For plants and plant products to earn the organic label, they need to have been grown in soil that hasn’t been treated by prohibited substances, which “include most synthetic fertilizers and pesticides.” 1
Packaged products generally have many ingredients, some of which can’t be grown organically. In these cases, the USDA requires that the products contain a minimum of 70% organically produced ingredients in order to use the word “organic” prominently on the packaging. For organic tampons, the organically produced ingredient is cotton. This means the main difference between organic and non-organic tampons usually comes down to how the cotton used in the tampons is grown.
Are organic tampons better? Breaking down the risks & benefits
So, what are the benefits of organic tampons compared to conventional tampons? The biggest argument for switching to organic is for the benefit of the planet at large—including the health and livelihoods of the cotton farmers with whom we share this planet.
People growing conventional cotton—especially in countries where environmental regulations are lax—have suffered from respiratory problems, poisonings, and other illnesses and hospitalizations. 2 And, of course, the pesticides and other chemicals used to grow conventional cotton are known to cause widespread environmental damage, polluting land and water bodies and killing plants, fish, and animals. 3
Clearly, organic tampons are better for the planet (at least, better than non-organic tampons). But are they better for your personal health? Turns out, not particularly.
BTW, if saving the earth is your M.O., there are now reusable period products on the market that will shrink your carbon footprint by a lot more than an organic tampon ever could. *Hint hint, menstrual cup*
But we digress…
While organic cotton is grown with fewer chemicals and pesticides than conventional cotton, all cotton has to be processed to a certain degree when it’s turned into a tampon. As a result, an organic label on a tampon doesn’t mean it’s free from harmful ingredients—and, likewise, the lack of an organic label doesn’t mean a tampon is filled with toxic chemicals.
Cotton vs. rayon vs. synthetics… oh my!
Let’s get to the bottom of the issue by looking at what tampons are actually made of. In the U.S., the Food and Drug Administration requires that tampons be made of cotton, rayon, or a blend of both. 4 All organic tampons are made with cotton since rayon, a material typically made from food pulp, cannot be certified organic.
A number of conventional tampons are made with rayon. Rayon got a bad rap in the 1990s because it was often bleached with chlorine gas, a method that created dioxins—toxic chemical compounds that can cause many health problems, including cancer. 5 However, companies stopped using chlorine gas to bleach tampons in the 1990s.
What about bleach?
Some organic tampons market themselves as being chlorine-free, but these days, neither organic nor conventional tampons are bleached with chlorine gas. Today’s tampons and pads—organic and conventional—contain very low levels of dioxins, far less than the amount we often get exposed to through food. 6
VOCs in other feminine hygiene products
Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are chemicals known to be harmful to human health and to the environment. Common VOCs include ethanol, formaldehyde, benzene, toluene and xylene. What do these compounds have to do with tampons, though?
Turns out, tampons and certain other feminine hygiene products do contain VOCs, as shown in a number of recent studies. 7 8 These chemicals are added during manufacturing either on purpose (i.e. as fragrances, adsorbents, moisture barriers, adhesives, or binders) or inadvertently, in which case they may be present as contaminants in raw materials or packaging.
You might think that buying organic tampons would surely keep you safe from VOCs—but this isn’t necessarily true. One 2020 study found that hygiene products labeled “organic,” “natural,” or “for sensitive skin” did not necessarily have lower VOC concentrations. 8 The same group of researchers identified the riskiest products as follows:
“For most [feminine hygiene products], calculated risks were low; however, menstrual pads had hazard ratios of up to 11, sprays and powders had hazard ratios of up to 2.2 and excess cancer risks of up to 2.1 × 10-6, and washes had excess cancer risks of up to 3.3 × 10-6.” 8
Translation? Pads, sprays, powders, and washes are the most worrisome VOC offenders, organic or not.
Can plastic tampon applicators cause problems?
Yes, tampon applicators can cause problems—most certainly for the environment. Because these applicators are single-use, disposable plastics that can end up polluting oceans and harming wildlife, some environmentalists have sought to get them banned altogether.
But do plastic tampon applicators directly harm the user? They could if they contain phthalates or other endocrine-disrupting chemicals found in many plastics.
A 2020 study of period products found phthalates, parabens, and bisphenols in pads, tampons, and other period products. The researchers determined the chemical exposure women were getting through the use of these products was “significant,” and noted that “feminine hygiene products are an important source of chemical exposure in women.” 9
If you’re concerned about chemicals from plastics, opt for tampons that have either no applicator or a paper applicator. Or ditch tampons and pads altogether and opt for a reusable, silicone menstrual cup or a disposable menstrual disc made from a medical-grade polymer.
Flex Disc, for instance, is made without BPAs, PFOAs, phthalates, or latex—and while it’s still a single-use product, it can be worn for 12 hours at a time. This means you’ll use fewer products each month and contribute significantly less waste than you would with plastic applicator tampons. Want to go 100% green? A menstrual cup like Flex Cup will last for years.
Do organic tampons shorten your period?
Hoping that switching to organic tampons will make your period end faster? Sorry—this gambit is unlikely to work. Medical experts say there’s no scientific evidence showing organic period products cut periods short. 10 We’re not entirely sure how this rumor was started, but there are other, scientifically-proven ways to shorten your period (we covered them in this recent blog post).
And while we’re on the topic: It’s always a good idea to talk to a healthcare professional if your period lasts longer than seven days on average or is suddenly much heavier than normal.
Breaking down TSS: Which period products come with a higher risk?
Now for the big question: What about toxic shock syndrome? Can organic tampons prevent or reduce the possibility of contracting TSS? Can any menstrual products?
According to medical researchers, organic tampons do not reduce the risk of TSS. 11 This is perhaps unsurprising, considering the fact that TSS is caused by staphylococcus aureus, a bacteria—and not by chemicals, pesticides, or other human-made pollutants.
Tampons aren’t the only period products that can trigger TSS. Pads, sponges, and menstrual cups can, too. So, which products are safe—or at least safer? To date, no TSS cases have been associated with a menstrual disc.
Protecting yourself from TSS has less to do with which products you use and more to do with how you use them. To stay safe, make sure to change your period product as frequently as recommended by the manufacturer. Don’t forget to remove your tampon—and avoid using tampons that are more absorbent than your period requires. Finally, always wash your hands before changing products.
Your vagina can’t tell the difference (so go with the product that works best for your lifestyle)
So, if you’re a lifelong tampon stan, which product should you buy? We might be a little biased, but here at Flex, we’re all for ditching tampons entirely and moving onto one of the more sustainable “next-gen” period product options on the market—like a menstrual cup or disc. But if you’re truly wedded to tampons and can’t imagine using anything else, that’s okay, too.
The answer really comes down to your personal preferences, values, and wallet. If you simply can’t afford to go organic, rest assured that you’re not directly causing harm to your body whenever you use a conventional tampon. If you can afford them, though, you might decide that the benefits to the planet at large are worth the extra cost.
Environmental concerns, however, are actually why many people switch from tampons and try out products like a menstrual disc, period cup, or period underwear. Menstrual cups are a reusable option that let you get away from disposables altogether, significantly reducing the amount of trash you produce. And menstrual discs, as the longest-wear disposable option, can dramatically reduce unnecessary waste.
Have other burning questions about organic period products or sustainability? Hit us up: Email firstname.lastname@example.org and we’ll get back to you right away.
This article is informational only and is not offered as medical advice, nor does it substitute for a consultation with your physician. If you have any gynecological/medical concerns or conditions, please consult your physician.
© 2021 The Flex Company. All Rights Reserved.